Pull quote: “Everything about the way that the scholarly literature is organized is based on the journal, the discipline and the scholarly community that connects those two things. Expecting first-years to get that from the outside is ridiculous. Expecting first years to get that because they’re taught about it by graduate students who are just becoming conversant with their own discourse community is ridiculous. And expecting first years to get that because they spend 50 minutes with a librarian is ridiculous.”